White Camellia
meets Musk Butterfly.
Compare the recorded scent profiles, then decide what to sample.
Geranium · Sandalwood
Both records list these notes. Shared notes do not guarantee the same smell.
Concentration not recorded leads with rose; Concentration not recorded leads with aldehydic. The table below separates their listed profiles and voting data.
| At a glance |  St. John White CamelliaConcentration not recorded Explore fragrance ↗ |  By Kilian Musk ButterflyConcentration not recorded Explore fragrance ↗ |
|---|---|---|
| Concentration | Concentration not recorded | Concentration not recorded |
| Listed bottle sizes | Not yet verified | Not yet verified |
| Brand origin | Not yet verified | Not yet verified |
| Made in | Not yet verified | Not yet verified |
| Listed year | 1998 | 2021 |
| Leading accords | rose · green · white floral | aldehydic · rose · fresh |
| Notes unique to this record | Jasmine, Cassis, Mandarin Orange, Rose, Green Notes, Peony, Musk, Amber | Aldehydes, Damask Rose, Turkish Rose, Litchi, Violet, Violet Leaf, Ambrette (Musk Mallow), Agarwood (Oud) |
| Longevity / 5 | 3.33 · 6 votes | 3.04 · 85 votes |
| Projection / 4 | 2.80 · 5 votes | 1.95 · 84 votes |
Scores are category averages, not hours or controlled measurements. Different vote samples are not a head-to-head wear test. “Unique” notes here means absent from the other record, not proof of a formula difference.
Ingredients, side by side.
Read the declared lists for the editions shown. Shared entries do not mean identical formulas, proportions or scent.
A label comparison will appear when both ingredient lists are verified for the same market.
White Camellia
Ingredient list not yet verified for this edition and market.
Musk Butterfly
Concentration unspecified on official page · US listing · 100 ml refill
Alcohol denat., Fragrance (parfum), Water\aqua\eau, Citronellol, Benzyl salicylate, Alpha-isomethyl ionone, Hexyl cinnamal, Hydroxycitronellal, Geraniol, Linalool, Coumarin, Farnesol, Eugenol, Benzyl alcohol, Citral, Limonene
Source: Kilian Paris official US size-specific ingredient list · Checked 2026-09-22 · Formula reference ILN48743
These are published ingredient declarations, separate from scent notes. “Parfum” or “fragrance” can represent a mixture without listing every component. Formulations can change by market and batch; check the packaging on your bottle. A matching or missing entry does not establish suitability for an allergy.
Follow your curiosity.
A starting point, not a verdictConcentration not recorded
Start here if the listed rose and green direction interests you. Try it on skin before deciding.
Concentration not recorded
Start here if the listed aldehydic and rose direction interests you. Try it on skin before deciding.